Soft Signals by Field Umpires Continue to Cause Controversy

Soft Signals by Field Umpires Continue to Cause Controversy
24.03.2021,13:03 105 0

Soft signals by on-field umpires are increasingly being criticised by players and observers of the game. An umpire may signal out in line with his stomach and draw a rectangle in the air to signal to the third umpire to check for conclusive evidence that could refute his decision. On another occasion, the umpire may cross his arms to convey a soft signal that the batsman is not out.

Yadav, Sundar Latest Victims of the Soft Signal

On 18 March, the on-field umpire in the 4th T20I between India and England gave Suryakumar Yadav out after a fielder, Dawid Malan, claimed a catch that was shown as touching the turf through the gap in his fingers. Yadav was ruled out by the third umpire, Virendra Sharma, who cited a lack of conclusive evidence to the contrary. On another occasion, Washington Sundar was caught on the fence by Adil Rashid who appeared to touch the boundary rope while completing the catch. On this occasion too, third umpire Sharma concurred with field umpire Ananthapadmanabhan’s soft signal to declare the batsman out.

Soft Signal Similar to Umpire’s Call in DRS

There is a similarity between the soft signal and the umpire’s call in DRS. In the umpire’s call, the 3rd umpire watches a video replay and reverts to the on-field umpire, effectively asking him to stay with his original decision of ‘out’ or ‘not out’.  The video shows whether the ball is clipping the bail or the impact of the ball on the pad is in line with the stumps.

Does the Soft Signal Serve its Ostensible Purpose?

Typically, in the case of the soft signal, the third umpire upholds the on-field umpire’s decision, with a display on the giant screen showing whether the batsman is out. What purpose does the soft signal serve? For instance, why doesn’t the on-field umpire use a soft signal for line decisions? Instead, he decides to go upstairs. One might argue that the accuracy of the line decisions depends on whether the batsman is within or without the crease, a fact that can be determined from replays on a TV screen. How does a soft signal differ?

Batsmen No Longer Enjoy Benefit of Doubt

The on-field umpire refers to the 3rd umpire with a soft signal when he has a doubt as to the correctness of his decision. The 3rd umpire who can rely on camera visions from many angles must be in the best position to say whether the on-field umpire has made the correct decision. But we understand that the 3rd umpire relies on 2D rather than 3D pictures to decide. Once, it was considered fair to give the benefit of the doubt to the batsman. Technology has made such a view redundant. Yet, neither the soft signal nor the umpire’s call is making optimal use of technology. As in the case of the umpire’s call, on being asked to adjudicate a soft signal, the 3rd umpire must rule decisively, regardless of the soft signal. Indian skipper Virat Kohli has suggested that umpires could use a ‘don’t know’ call that would bring in more clarity and allow better decisions, given that some decisions can turn the course of a game.

Liked? Share:
33   voted

Responses (0)

Similar news
Mushfiqur Rahim Nominated for ICC Men's Player of the Month May 2021
Mushfiqur Rahim Nominated for ICC Men’s Player of the Month May 2021
Read more

Bangladesh hosted Sri Lanka in an ICC Cricket World Cup Super League series in May 2021. The Man of the Series award for the competition went to Bangladesh’s wicket-keeper-batsman Mushfiqur Rahim. The former Bangladesh skipper finds his name among three nominated for the ICC Men’s Player of the Month award for May 2021. The two […]

Pakistan Cricket Board Plans to Host 5 Major ICC Events from 2024-2031
Pakistan Cricket Board Plans to Host 5 Major ICC Events from 2024-2031
Read more

The ICC can expect a bid to host five major ICC events from the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) in the 2024-2031 cycle when cricket’s governing body begins the process for the next cycle. The PCB is reportedly interested in hosting ICC T20 and ODI world cups, in addition to the Champions Trophy. If the PCB’s […]

Sri Lanka Players to Tour England Without Contracts
Sri Lanka Players to Tour England Without Contracts
Read more

Following a commitment by Sri Lanka Cricket that the board would reveal specifics relating to player evaluations on which the new proposed contract scheme was based, Sri Lanka men’s players have agreed to tour England without contracts. The cricketers had long accused SLC of a lack of transparency in the methodology adopted by the board […]

Dhawan to Lead India on Sri Lanka Tour
Dhawan to Lead India on Sri Lanka Tour
Read more

The BCCI has called up uncapped players Chetan Sakariya, K Gowtham, Nitish Rana, Ruturaj Gaikwad and Devdutt Padikkal while selecting the 20-man squad to tour Sri Lanka for a white-ball series in July. Shikhar Dhawan will lead the second-string squad, the main Indian team on tour in England at the time, with Bhuvneshwar Kumar as […]

Dream11 Gloucestershire vs Sussex: June 11, Vitality Blast 2021 Prediction
Dream11 Gloucestershire vs Sussex: June 11, Vitality Blast 2021 Prediction
Read more

Gloucestershire vs Sussex Match Details In this article, we preview and make a Dream11 prediction for Gloucestershire vs Sussex, the Vitality Blast T20 game to be held in Bristol on June 11. Team Sussex Report Likely XI: Ali Orr, Tom Haines, Stiaan van Zyl, Aaron Thomason, Travis Head, Ben Brown, Danial Ibrahim, Jack Carson, Stuart […]

Gloucestershire vs Sussex: June 11, Vitality Blast 2021 Prediction
Gloucestershire vs Sussex: June 11, Vitality Blast 2021 Prediction
Read more

In this article, we preview Gloucestershire vs Sussex, the Vitality Blast 2021 match to be played on 11 June 2021 at County Ground, Bristol. Match Predictions and Team Previews Analysis The last time Gloucestershire faced Sussex in the Vitality Blast was on 30 August 2019 in Hove. In that match, Sussex batted first. After losing […]