Controversial Coded Signal System from England Dressing Room to Field
During England’s T20I series in South Africa, Nathan Leamon, England team analyst, communicated from England’s dressing room balcony with the team on the field using clipboards with numbers and letters on them. The cards that had messages such as 5E and 3B were said to be references to historical data relating to how certain batsmen played certain bowlers. The clipboard messages could influence Morgan’s bowling changes on the field. The real-time coded signals have set off a debate among media and in cricketing circles.
England Skipper Morgan says the System is Beneficial
England skipper Eoin Morgan has stated that there was nothing wrong with the use of such signals which were ‘within the spirit of the game’. Speaking to a media outlet, Morgan is quoted as saying, “It’s about maximising information that we’re taking in, and measuring it against things (like) coaches’ recommendations, the data, what’s going on.” Morgan added that the team was going to continue with it, using a sufficiently large sample size to see whether it made a difference to or improved performance or decision making on the field.
The England captain pointed out that there were different types of captains. According to Morgan, one type of captain was content with enjoying the title and the power and the accolades that went with it. A second type included those who continued to be pushed and wanted to “learn for the benefit of the team.” Morgan said that he belonged to the second group. Morgan construes the coded signal system as something they were going to use “to try and help myself and the other leaders in the side.” He wanted it as a tool that could help compare the emotion underscoring on-field decision making with hard data.
Former England Captain Vaughan is Not Amused
The England camp have cleared the use of the messages with the anti-corruption officials and the match referee, Andy Pycroft. But not everybody is amused by the idea of using coded signals from the dugout to the players in the middle. Interestingly, former England captain Michael Vaughan is one of the most vocal critics of the coded communication system, dismissing it with a single word, “nonsense!” He expressed his derision via a tweet: “Signals sent from an analyst on a balcony to the captain on the pitch!!!! The world has officially gone nuts!!!” According to Vaughan, such information could be passed on privately.
Flirting with Controversy: Memories of the Past
The incident reminds us of the 1999 World Cup in England when South Africa skipper Hansie Cronje received instructions from team coach Bob Woolmer through an earpiece worn by the skipper. The ICC acted quickly to outlaw the move which caused a lot of controversy at the time. There is a ban in place on any form of electronic communication in cricket. The England team is clearly seen pushing the envelope hard at exploiting a loophole in the rules relating to live information resources. What if they went too far? We remember the controversy that ensued during Australia’s tour of India in 2017 when Steve Smith appeared to gesture towards the dressing room to help decide whether to ask for a review against an LBW decision taken by the on-field umpire.
We preview Sri Lanka vs England, the 3rd T20 of a three-match series on Sri Lanka’s tour of England. The match will be played on June 26, 2021, at Southampton, a venue at which both teams have won one match each against the other. With both teams using the series as preparation for the world […]
We preview and make our match prediction in respect of Sri Lanka vs England, the 2nd T20I of a three-game series on SL’s tour of England. The match will be played at Cardiff on June 24, 2021. England who have named a full-strength squad are favourites to win against a Sri Lanka squad led by […]
In this article, we preview Sri Lanka vs England, the 1st T20 of a 3-match series on Sri Lanka’s tour of England, to be played on June 23, 2021, at Cardiff. Both teams are expected to use the series as preparation for the T20I world cup scheduled to be held later this year. Match Predictions […]
Sri Lanka are scheduled to tour England for the white-ball series to be played between 23 June and 4 July. But the Sri Lanka squad will be without their star all-rounder Angelo Mathews whose wife is reportedly pregnant with their third child. The all-rounder has opted out of the England tour owing to paternity leave. […]
Pakistan are scheduled to tour England between 8 and 20 July to play three ODIs and three T20Is. Subsequently, they will tour West Indies to play five T20Is and two Tests. Azam Khan, a hard-hitting batsman who represents Quetta Gladiators in the PSL, has been named for the T20 series versus West Indies and England. […]
The ICC is reported to be keen to shift the 2021 men’s T20 World Cup to the UAE. International cricket’s governing body is also reportedly looking at a third venue, Oman, that could co-host the competition if the ICC decides not to host it in India. BCCI Given Time Until 28 June to Decide The […]