Should Rohit Sharma Captain India in T20I Matches?

Should Rohit Sharma Captain India in T20I Matches?
01.12.2020,15:12 157 0

Rohit Sharma recently led Mumbai Indians to their fifth IPL title and revived a debate that had been dormant for a while. It’s an argument that has been brewing for a while: should Rohit Sharma replace Virat Kohli as captain in T20I matches? Various observers, including past and present cricketers, have weighed in with their opinions on the subject. In this article, we look at the pros and cons of replacing Kohli with Sharma as India’s T20I captain.

Arguments in Favour

  • If players can be picked based on their performance in the IPL, then why not captains? This is an argument favoured by Gautam Gambhir, former India player and former IPL skipper (Kolkata Knight Riders and Delhi Capitals). This addresses the objection of some that the IPL is not comparable with international cricket.
  • Sharma is a better T20 captain than Kohli. Whereas Sharma has led five successful title campaigns for Mumbai Indians, Kohli is yet to win the title for Royal Challengers Bangalore. This is hard to argue against, going by the captaincy records of the two in the IPL.
  • Picking Sharma as skipper of India’s T20I side will give Kohli a breather. Kohli has his plate full in terms of being India’s best batsman across formats as well as captain of the ODI and Test sides. So, relieving him from the captaincy of the T20I side would help reduce stress in a crowded cricket calendar. Former England captain Michael Vaughan recommends this measure, saying, “it works for all other teams around the world.”

Arguments Against

  • Splitting the captaincy across formats can cause confusion and reduce synergy within the Indian team which has about 70 percent of players performing across formats. Former Indian all-rounder and skipper Kapil Dev backs this argument.
  • IPL and international cricket cannot be compared. In the IPL, franchise owners have a big say on how teams are managed and skippered. Captains of international teams, by comparison, can impose their views, especially in matters such as team selection.
  • Kohli’s captaincy record in T20Is is exemplary. He has won 24 of 37 matches skippered while losing only 11. Also, Kohli appears to thrive on pressure. The additional responsibility appears to bring out the best in him as a batsman.

Summary

We tend to agree with Akash Chopra who points out that Virat Kohli has done brilliantly well as India’s T20I captain. Compare the win percentages: while Sharma has won 60% of his games as captain of Mumbai Indians in the IPL, Kohli has emerged victorious in 72% of the matches in which he has led India. Chopra also makes a valid point when he asks whether the selectors should drop such player as KL Rahul from the Indian T20I team if he had a poor IPL season with the bat, underscoring that Rahul is a proven performer in international cricket. Chopra also rebuts the argument that Kohli does well as India’s T20I captain as he has been handed a strong team by pointing out that Rohit Sharma has enjoyed his success at the helm of Mumbai Indians who are a strong IPL team. There is no denying that Sharma is a good T20 captain, but if Kohli continues to do well at India’s helm, there is no reson to replace him as skipper.

Liked? Share:
0   voted

Responses (0)

Similar news
BCCI to Discuss Overseas Players Availability for IPL with Other Boards
BCCI to Discuss Overseas Players Availability for IPL with Other Boards
Read more

The BCCI met at a Special General Meeting on May 29 to decide to play the second leg of the IPL in the UAE. The BCCI also discussed plans to talk with other cricket boards regarding the availability of players with the respective boards during the September-October window in which the IPL is due to […]

Crowds Likely to Be Allowed for The Second Leg of IPL in the UAE
Crowds Likely to Be Allowed for The Second Leg of IPL in the UAE
Read more

The BCCI has had a busy time in recent days with several announcements and developments. The IPL 2021 was compulsorily suspended by the BCCI on 4 May, following a surge of Covid-19 cases within the bio-bubble. Subsequently, an announcement from the BCCI has revealed the plan of holding the second leg of the 14th edition […]

Remaining Matches of IPL 2021 Will Be Played in UAE from September 18
Remaining Matches of IPL 2021 Will Be Played in UAE from September 18
Read more

The IPL 2021 competition is set to resume in the UAE in September-October. The BCCI made the decision at a virtually held special general body meeting on 22 May. The governing board of Indian cricket will also reportedly ask the ICC for an extended time to decide whether to hold the men’s 2021 T20 World […]

BCCI Expected to Put Tender Plans for New IPL Teams on Hold
BCCI Expected to Put Tender Plans for New IPL Teams on Hold
Read more

With the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic causing disruption in the functioning of the board, the BCCI has put plans to organise a tender for new IPL franchises on the backburner. Instead, the current interest of the BCCI is to finalise a schedule for the resumption of the IPL 2021 competition in which several matches […]

Reports Suggest IPL Could Resume in September
Reports Suggest IPL Could Resume in September
Read more

The IPL 2021 tournament which began on 9 April was stopped midway on 4 May after a breach of the bio-bubble led to a spate of Covid-19 cases among staff and players of various franchises. There is a question mark over the fate of the rest of the competition with an increasing number of Covid-19 […]

Lanka Premier League 2021 to Begin on July 30
Lanka Premier League 2021 to Begin on July 30
Read more

Sri Lanka Cricket has announced that it plans to host the second season of the Lanka Premier League (LPL) between 30 July and 22 August. Professor Arjuna De Silva, chair of SLC’s Management Committee, has said to media outlets, “We have found a suitable window to hold this year’s edition, whilst we are currently working […]